← Today’s edition

legal · South Africa

We Smell an Agenda

Editorial image for We Smell an Agenda
75

🌿 Plant Truth Index

Plant Forward

Reform partner publication

🌿 Reform Vanguard🤝 Community & Heritage⚖️ Constitutional Precedent
Progressive42%
Rigour46%
Local76%

90+ Stigma Breaker · 70+ Plant Forward · 40+ Factual Record · below 40 Prohibition Echo

In the news this week a political furore erupted around the Sudanese President, the ICC and the African Union. Are these international treaties worth anything? South Africa is a signatory to the United Nations 1961 Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs. So seeing as our nation’s signature in the international rule books has been in the

In the news this week a political furore erupted around the Sudanese President, the ICC and the African Union. Are these international treaties worth anything?

South Africa is a signatory to the United Nations 1961 Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs. So seeing as our nation’s signature in the international rule books has been in the news this week, we thought we would give you some insight into what is going on in this regard right here in SA. Should South Africa take the lead from Uruguay and legislate in contravention of the international agreements? We were given an insight into the world of this UN Convention when Dr Lochan Naidoo made a presentation to the hearings held by the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Health. He was commenting on the Medial Innovation Bill.

https://www.fieldsofgreenforall.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Dr-Naidoo_President_International-Narcotics-Control-Board.mp3

↑↑↑Here is the recording (35mins) and an abbreviated transcript of Dr Naidoo’s speech. Remember that he is the doctor who said that opiates are not addictive? He uses a slide during his presentation that attempts to illustrate Cannabis causing cognitive “holes” in the brain but all we could find were huge holes in his approach, pointing to his agenda as a purveyor of private addiction therapy and training. This is not a hidden agenda, just one that is playing to the audience. As you heard in our last recordings , the audience at the hearings comprised of some seriously under-informed people, as well as others with various funding agendas.

Dr Naidoo is keeping his audience just that little bit in the dark. He is not saying anything about the fact that the walls are tumbling down around the UN Drugs Conventions. Fields of Green for ALL is a member of a steering committee as part of the Global Forum of Producers of Prohibited Plants. This committee reports to the Civil Society Task Force at #UNGASS2016 in New York in April 2016. The conversation is vastly more sophisticated and advanced than Dr Naidoo’s simplistic rants about addiction.

Dr_Naidoo_Bio_and_Transcript_MIB_Hearings For in-depth commentary on the #UNGASS2016 conference see http://www.tdpf.org.uk/blog/real-un-debate-around-war-drugs-and-war-youth#.VX_QPLbu3V8.twitter As far as the South African Government ignoring a High Court Order goes, we should prepare ourselves to defend the order legalising Cannabis when it is granted. That is not an IF, it is a WHEN! When it comes to politics it is a slippery road.

Why DaggaBay rated it this way

Filed as Watchdog alert — a constitutional & legal story with objective record framing, anchored on High Court, Legislation.

46%

Evidence rigour

76%

Local impact

15

Evidence and watchdog value

  • “addict”stigma signal · weight 15
  • “narcotic”anti signal · weight 6
  • “legalis”pro signal · weight 2

Historical context

How this framing got here

  • South Africa's first cannabis restrictions, from 1870 onward, targeted Indian indentured labourers and African mine workers — not the substance's measured harm.
  • The 1928 push to schedule cannabis internationally was driven by the South African delegation, exporting a locally racialised policy to the world.
  • Prohibition-era 'dangerous drug' language survived into modern reporting, which is why the phrase reads as a scientific finding when it is an administrative one.
  • Enforcement stayed racially skewed long after 1994, with cannabis charges concentrated in poor and rural communities.